A few days ago I was tagged by Vijay with the $456 Billion meme. This was started by Sam of Blog, MD who was inspired by the Boston Globe feature ‘What does $456 Billion buy‘. The original article suggested several US orientated possibilities but also quotes figures from the World Bank suggesting that $54 billion a year would eliminate starvation and malnutrition globally by 2015, while $30 billion would provide a year of primary education for every child on earth. Wow, that’s some serious issues that it would have funded.
I’ve been thinking for a few days about how to answer this and am still struggling. Vijay set the bar quite high with his post about Tuberculosis in India. When you start thinking in terms of saving people’s lives it becomes difficult to find other options to spend it on. I don’t think I will start quoting a lot of figures, otherwise the research will suck me in and this post will never get made.
Anyway, once you have eliminated diseases, (I wish it were that easy,) you then need to grow crops to feed the people, as otherwise living in starvation is no quality of life. Then it makes you think about the ‘food mountains’ that we have in the west which allows us to maintain price stability in the markets and just how wrong this is. In 2006 the EU food mountain exceeded 13 million tonnes. We in Europe are paying to store food, I read in one article 1 million a month, and destroy it if it is unused, while people are starving. Maybe instead of storing it, we spend a little of the money to ship the food to where it is needed as soon as it is produced. If the US can grow rice and ship it to Japan, then I’m sure it can be shipped to anywhere. There will always be arguments who will pay for it, but hey who’s paying to store it? OK, so I’ve eliminated disease, fed the world, now on to improving quality of life. People need hope that tomorrow will be better than today and next week will be better than this. In the many drought and war torn countries, I don’t know what the answer is. I’m sure that money will help, but I’m just not sure how, maybe through providing education so that the people can see their own solution to their plight and with funding improve life day by day. Maybe if the situation was stable, and the people not starving, businesses would look to invest in the poorer countries. Unfortunately, I’ll be cynical here, many businesses will probably only invest because the labour might be cheaper than the current locations.
I know it will probably not happen for a long time, but we need to start thinking on a more global, ‘what is the right thing’, rather than the current insular, ‘what can I get from it’
Hmm, I think I’ve deviated from the meme a lot and had better stop here before I loose the plot completely.
As this has made me think so much, I had better tag Ilker at the Thinking Blog. I will also tag Gary, KyleBeabo and Becky
Warning: Declaration of Social_Walker_Comment::start_lvl(&$output, $depth, $args) should be compatible with Walker_Comment::start_lvl(&$output, $depth = 0, $args = Array) in /homepages/9/d69875426/htdocs/ianblog_wp/wp-content/plugins/social/lib/social/walker/comment.php on line 18
Warning: Declaration of Social_Walker_Comment::end_lvl(&$output, $depth, $args) should be compatible with Walker_Comment::end_lvl(&$output, $depth = 0, $args = Array) in /homepages/9/d69875426/htdocs/ianblog_wp/wp-content/plugins/social/lib/social/walker/comment.php on line 42
OK, this is more like it. I was tagged by Rob too and I was totally intimidated by his and Vijay’s response. So I have been using my vacation as an excuse to avoid it for the moment. Now you have brought it down to earth I will endeavour to complete it before Rob gives up on me.
regards
jmb
Ian, I agree that the numbers are very intimidating.
I should confess that as a doctor in India, I’m used to the enormous numbers that our census and epidemiological data provide. I followed Rob’s example and tried to fit in the numbers.
Even then, my post underwent numerous revisions, which continued after I thought I had finally proofed and published it. Anyone who had seen the first version would agree.
I made a lot of stupid arithmetic mistakes – which, incidentally I’m notorious for among my medical college mates. I once got the wrong answer for dividing 1500 by 3 ๐
Thanks for taking up the tag and giving your views.
Each of our responses is a direct indictment of the utterly wasteful war that is being so zealously fought.
JMB, Don’t be so parsimonious. It isn’t really our money. So spend it as you wish ๐ I’ll wait for a good effort from you.
Thanks for the meme tag Ian, I’ve put my contribution up at http://blog.azazil.net/321-how-to-spend-456-billion.html, and you might even be surprised that I didn’t use any of it to reinstate the รยฃ110bn so publicly lost from the UK pension fund by our bungling future prime minister (I’m not a civil servant anymore, so I’m actually allowed to be critical of the government now!) ๐ I was tempted… but I found a more interesting way to make use of it…
Thanks for your comments. This started off last night with the intent that once I had started it, I would add to it over the next couple of days and then post it. That didn’t happen, so you got it raw and rambling. Go for it jmb, spend it how you want, Gary did and in such an unexpected way. Brilliant!
Thanks Vijay for tagging me and Gary for taking up the baton.
Ian